The Human Touch in HR and Payroll

Reading Time: 4 minutes
Add as a preferred source on Google

With the advent of AI, artificial intelligence is permeating all tech tools – and the solutions you use to steer payroll are experiencing the same shift. The question on everyone’s lips is: how is a machine replacing man? Yet, this is perhaps a misunderstood view of what AI is allowing humans to do. Instead, we should ask: how can man add value in a way that machines can’t?

Payroll is a function that fits squarely between human resources and the financial department. The technology it uses is particularly helpful because it helps spot genuine errors and helps save payroll staff’s time. Tasks are reduced to numbers, transfers and data in cloud computing. This is useful for cross-collaborative teams, but what about the humanness of it?

“Payroll and HR both deal with people’s livelihoods and influence personal circumstances,” says Sandra Crous, Managing Director of Deel Local Payroll powered by PaySpace. “Technology can make processes faster and more accurate, but it does not replace empathy and sound judgement. Employees need to know that when something goes wrong, there is a real person who can listen and help.”

According to a survey by Deel, half of employees check their payslips weekly, and a third express confusion about deductions.

“When someone comes to you with a payroll issue, that’s not an annoyance. That’s a big part of the job, and the best payroll people want to help. You show patience and interest because the employee either has found a genuine error, or they need guidance, which you are the best qualified to provide,” Crous explains.

“The best systems give HR and payroll teams more time for those conversations by handling routine work reliably. So, it really is a win-win.”

Automation Shouldn’t Replace the Human Element

As Crous notes, the real problem comes in when automation is introduced to reduce human involvement, rather than to improve the experience. “If a system makes it difficult to resolve a situation, explain a payslip or correct an error, people can feel ignored. Automation should take care of repetitive tasks while keeping people available for decisions, exceptions and sensitive conversations.”

Payroll teams want more time and bandwidth to deal with high-value engagements, such as helping people resolve specific payroll issues. At the same time, many resist automation, fearing that it will make them obsolete and replaceable.

In reality, automation doesn’t threaten payroll employees. They allow teams to focus on specific concerns and ensure accurate payroll.

However, Crous also explains why employees are anxious about automation: It’s due to the common mistakes they make when introducing automation in a business. “Teams start by automating an existing process before checking whether the process is accurate and well understood. That can make errors happen faster and at a much larger scale.

“Teams should first map the process, identify where people need to make decisions, and involve payroll staff in what to automate. They should also test carefully, keep clear checks, and make sure there is a straightforward way to handle exceptions,” she adds.

Additionally, a study published in the International Journal of Business Quantitative Economics and Applied Management Research found that “automation does not lead to job loss but rather a redistribution of tasks. Routine administrative functions are automated, while professionals take on more valuable and strategic responsibilities, such as leadership development, employee engagement, and organisational development.”

Cloud-based Payroll and HR Systems Offer More than Automation

Another misunderstood part of using cloud-based payroll and human resource management systems is that it is simply necessary for convenience and controlled access. But it offers so much more, and small businesses in particular can benefit from these features.

Some of the features that can effectively be automated in small businesses include:

  • Compliance and legislation: Leading payroll platforms actively push new legislative updates, including updates to calculations. While payroll staff are informed of the new updates, they don’t have to implement them.
  • Employee self-service: Payroll teams get considerable amounts of time back if their payroll software has self-service (ESS) portals where employees access payslips, leave requests, and other tasks.
  • Multistep workflows: Payroll staff create workflows that automatically handle multi-step approval, information gathering, and calculation processes, feeding automated reporting and audit trails.
  • eOnboarding: New employees use online forms and document submission to proactively start onboarding processes. Staff in different departments use configurable workflows that capture and validate key details upfront.

“Small businesses often have limited HR resources, so manual administration can take valuable time away from running the business,” Crous reiterates. “Good e-onboarding will help capture correct employee data from the start, while self-service lets employees access data themselves, empowering them to apply for leave, read company policies, and be in the know without dependence on the payroll office. A robust system should make these tasks simple, protect personal information and support accurate payroll as the business scales.”

She elaborates that payroll teams’ confidence comes from having accurate data, dependable calculations, clear checks, and a reliable record of changes. “For employees, on the other hand, it comes from being paid correctly and on time, understanding their payslips and knowing where to get help if something does not look right. A robust product reduces avoidable uncertainty while keeping people available to resolve the issues that need human attention.

“Good automation relies on a foundation that understands the many processes that payroll and HR rely on and has technical features which create the flexibility and security to create good automation. The goal is to make everyone’s lives easier, for payroll people, employees, and other departments,” she concludes.

Maryna Steyn - author photo

Written by
Maryna Steyn

Maryna Steyn is a vibrant writer and editor with a passion for language. She is a published author, writer and poet who has honed her skills in journalism and editing across various industries such as learning design, lifestyle, agriculture, media, and now, business. She believes in life long learning and has obtained multiple certifications in learning design, design and writing since completing her BA degree in Communication Science from UNISA. Today, she steers the editorial ship at SME South Africa, proudly bringing insight and knowledge to the South African small business space.

Get Weekly 5-Minutes Business Advice

Global Subscription Form
Global Subscription Form